But didn't want to spend much money, as I mentioned in Peat's cuke thread. So... the materials for this cheap hydroponic setup were $4.72, plus stuff I had on hand. And though more lights and aeration would be better, we'll see how far they can get without. Sort of like an indoor version of Judith's trashcan cukes so far.
Harvest total: 3.5 - first cuke February 26th, potted cuke aged 10.5 weeks.
Grow ended at 15 weeks.
2009-11-01: Planted tendergreen cucumber seeds in fat Park Seed sponges in Dixie cups, germinated on Pro100 deck. This cuke produced the most cukes this summer out of 4 varieties grown - seems flexible.
2009-11-04: Roots emerged from sponges before leaves. Built dishtub rig and stuffed the sponges in, plus 1.75 gallons of 0.7 EC FloraMato solution in tap water.
2009-11-16: Removed lower cuke - as its first true leave unfurled, found it had rot on it, too. Don't want contagion spreading to the good cuke. (Was eventually going to cull to one cuke plant, anyway. Just not before flowering...)
2009-11-23: Added a bit of pH down, shooting for ~5.5 pH a la Peat's grows. (But can't really mix the tub well, nor measure exactly, so not sure what pH it actually is right now...)
2009-11-24: Yikes... Two biggest leaves crashed. pH was down near 4... Added pH up... Now around 6.
2009-12-2: Spent another $10 on the project and added an airstone, running 6 hours a day (2-3 hours overlap with end of light cycle, then running during the dark.)
2009-12-5: Complete drain and refill, with pH (~6) and EC (1.8) tested FloraMato in rainwater. Also replaced fluorescent tubes - not noticeably brighter. Kept old tubes - will need to add another shoplight soon. First male flower bloomed today. Not done yet with the brown-on-main-veins disease that kills leaves.
2009-12-8: Complete drain and fill again, to clean out brown gunk. This time actually washed the tub, didn't just syphon it off... pH ~6, EC ~1.6, rainwater and maybe 1/8 tap, FloraMato with 1/2 tsp added Miracle Gro Bloom fertilizer, a la Beth's Aerogarden cuke.
2009-12-19: Dishtub cuke 1 (tendergreen) terminated at 7 weeks. Flowered great, but all leaves got rot when they reached a certain size. Made way for new experiment :
Round 2: Cucino cuke, dishtub vs. pot head to head.
2009-12-14: Planted 2 cucino cucumbers in fat Park Starts plugs - germinate on pro100 deck.
2009-12-19: 5 days, roots emerging from plugs. Transferred cucino seedlings to pot and fresh dishtub.
2010-01-28: 6.5 weeks, both cukes opened their first flowers today.
2010-01-31: Discarded dishtub cuke, whose vine crashed after setting fruit. 
2010-02-28: Moved potted cuke - needed seedling shelf space.
2010-03-30: Deleted plant. Just wasn't productive enough - less than 1 little cuke a week.
That is a great idea! It's so simple
Thanks, Baldy2! Fingers crossed...
In retrospect, I think the hydroton growrocks are superfluous here. Probably could have just tied the net really tight to the bottle tops to provide a bottom, then suspended the sponges that way from the flimsy lid.
Yay, welcome to the hydroponic cuke growing club. 
Could you not have got it any cheaper?
Looking forward to seeing how this progresses with your FloraMato, it's a great little idea.
Thanks re the welcome to the cuke club. I could have scrimped further, yeah. 
The goal being to make the harvest cost less than buying cucumbers, electricity included. Of course, I don't buy supermarket cukes, because I got spoiled and they don't taste good to me anymore. But you know what I mean. 
Hi Gisette,
How cool! Looking forward to your grow!
Beth
So far so good.
They look about normal for 1 week cuke seedlings.
There being a lot of extra light atm, added a little heatwave lettuce buddy. Yes, I could make another dishtub for them, but the idea with this unit is that I can move it around to use spillover light wherever, even put it in a cold window now and then. Planted the same time as the cukes. I started two lettuce pods for this, but one got repurposed.
Another good idea! Yea!
Enjoy!
(I did learn, with my outside trashcan cukes, that some varieties don't care for this method - just keep that in mind as you grow)
Good info, Judith! Which varieties you tried liked/disliked the trashcan? Of course, it may be hard to tell, vs. weather and bugs, etc.
Dishtub cukes coming along. The right one is higher / closer to lights, and vibrantly healthy. The seed leaves seem damaged on the left one - may or may not get past that when its true leaf is in business.
The right plant looks about the same as the same-age cuke I grew under these lights in potting soil during the summer. (Different cuke variety, but similar.)
Parks "Diva" didn't care for the trash can treatment. It did produce, but not much, and the bugs really liked it. The ones I harvested tasted really good tho. I just might try it again after the cooler weather leaves. Maybe it'll do better before the horrid heat comes again.
Enjoy!
Hi Gisette,
Looking good! I hope we all get some early winter cucs!
Beth
Definitely, fingers crossed on everyone's early winter cukes! 
Thanks, Judith, re the Park's Diva. Interesting. This tendergreen cuke isn't my favorite of the 4 I grew this summer (I prefer both Japanese and Pearl), but it sure seemed the most tolerant of bad conditions, and most likely to have more than 2 cukes developing at once. And they're good - far better than anything I've had from an American supermarket.
Dishtub cuke coming along, has buds inside - a full tuft developed and starting to extend. Has lesions on oldest true leaf - hopefully nothing serious.
Flushed a gallon of liquids with fresh rain/nutes. EC 1.8, pH 6.x atm. (I didn't raise the pH - that's just what it came to after refreshing.) No aeration.
Removed 2nd cuke as its first true leaf had rot in addition to lesions on seed leaves. Never meant for two cukes in here indefinitely, anyway.
Yikes.
Added pH Down last night and didn't check the pH - I used less pH Down than I normally use of pH Up on my Deluxe - and the dishtub has over twice as much liquid. Figured I'd just test it today and adjust further, after it had time to mix properly. It went down to 4.0...or lower.
Don't want to make this mistake again.
Pretty major setback for the cuke.
pH now around 6 - I can't measure it any closer.
Poor plant, it will recover though as my last cuke went through some tough pH times and bounced back.
Looking good so far though.
Peat - good to hear! Your plant bounced back and produced great!
I was so bummed to see it this morning, too - expected great things and found ... that.
Today the cuke's first male flower bloomed - 5 weeks. (No picture of that - kid has camera.)
Spent some more time and money this week. Wednesday, invested another $10 on a cheap airstone and pump (Walmart). So far, the cuke hadn't had any aeration - which was also true of Judith's trashcan cukes, so I thought I might get away with it. But the brown-veins leaf-killing disease continues, so... maybe this'll help. The plant looked greener almost instantly, though it seemed plenty green before.
Today, complete drain and refill with pH-and-EC tested FloraMato in rainwater. (pH ~6, EC ~1.8) I hadn't been testing pH on new nutes... bad idea. FloraMato + rainwater = pH around 5 or below...
Also replaced the fluorescent tubes. Not noticeably brighter, but the lettuce seemed kinda pale. Want to add a second 2-tube shoplight before the cuke bears fruit.
Hi Gisette,
I find that the Floramato is very acidic. I've let it sit, and it still stays well below 5.0. I need to add at least 35 drops of pH up to get it to 6.0. Very annoying. With the ag cuc, I broke down and added a 1/4 tsp of MG bloom because the plants are declining with the floramato. It seems to be holding its own at the moment. No babies maturing yet.
Beth
Be careful & keep an eye on your grow. I had a VERY BAD experience with the WalMart air stones. They disintegrated in the AG!. I had to completely empty, clean & disinfect my AG. Never again!
Beth - interesting! I have some MG bloom, might give that a whirl. Yeah, I was surprised how acidic the FloraMato is. Well, now I know... Testing pH is a pain, but clearly I need to do it more often using this stuff.
Judith - oops, good to know re the Walmart airstone, thanks! It does look cheap. Actually, it doesn't look like a stone at all - a plastic bar with kind of a "stone" diffuser strip glued onto one side.
Are you doing trashcan cukes again this season?
Sounds like a different 'airstone' than I had. Mine looked like a small round, green, airstone.
Yes, I'll be putting more cucumbers in the trashcan about mid to late February. Unless we get warm sooner. Right now the green bell pepper plants, in a trash can, are still growing out there. No peppers right now, but the plants are doing fine in spite of the cold we've had. Weird.
Enjoy!
Great, Judith! Good luck with the peppers!
Got my camera back.
Younger part of plant looking great, three male flowers have bloomed so far, but the two biggest leaves are already goners. I looked around at cuke leaf diseases, and don't find this, and haven't seen it in Peat or Beth's grows, either. The lesions form right at the main leaf veins. So, my theory remains that it's leaf damage from sweating too-acid nutes. But, if any more leaves die of this (and I keep on top of the nute pH), that blows that theory.
Just saw this new brown icky precipitate for the first time today. Dunno what that's about... Maybe I can skim it out.
Edit: Hmph. Just retested pH, and it's drifted up this time, to maybe 6.5. Decided to leave it, the plant looks happy, and an inch or three longer than it was yesterday... I have leftover nutes from that batch in a jug, and those are definitely still down around 6.0. Funky.
Yuck, I wonder what you have here? Possible hydroton residue?
I think I'd be inclined to flush the whole lot away rather than skim it off, if you are able to do that.
Yeah... well, skimming didn't work, particularly. It's just sad to toss all that rainwater when I just replaced the nutes Saturday. 
I don't know what it is. I left the cuke roots dry (well, the tub empty) for maybe an hour, thinking fresh air would be good for them and they wouldn't dry out in that short a time. Maybe something anaerobic living on the roots or hydroton that died from all the air? There's hydroton residue in the picture, too, but that's like fine red-brown sand - doesn't float around. No smell...
Based on everybody's feedback (thank you!!!) and having gotten around to feeling like it (that and rainfall are key limiting factors
) - tonight I completely drained and refilled the cuketub again, to clean out brown gunk. This time actually washed the roots and tub, didn't just syphon it off... pH ~6, EC ~1.6, rainwater and maybe 1/8 tap, FloraMato with 1/2 tsp added Miracle Gro Bloom fertilizer, a la Beth's Aerogarden cuke (in about 1.8 gallons).
At this point, conditions should be pretty similar to Beth's AG grow, but with 2x the reservoir, different 2-sex cuke variety, and long light rather than intense light. Probably 3x the useful light volume or more. I hope. But - it may need more intense light.
It's flowering a lot (all male). It's still losing leaves, but at least the latest sick leaf has a different pattern to it. 
I read somewhere online that you can strew used coffee grounds on top of potting soil to deter gnats. I'm thinking that's a much easier approach to growing indoor cukes, if it works. Anybody tried it? Or maybe just a plastic wrap a la plastic mulch would help.
This cuke is not growing quicker, bigger, or better, in any way, than the cuke I had in a self-watering pot of potting mix under the same lights this summer. It certainly isn't growing as well as Beth's Earthbox cukes-under-lights. And the fact that Beth found her cukes did better by reducing water - at first, though later they may want more - is kinda telling.
Dishtub cuke is not doing well. New nutes, religious pH checking, air stone - no luck. Before any leaf gets big, it still rots from the inner veins out, browns, and dies. I do like the way this particular variety of cuke doesn't let a little (lot!!!) of leaf death get in the way of it flowering. Pathetic as it looks, I think it would yet produce cukes. (Not from these male flowers, of course.) But it's not well.
I bought some cucino cuke seeds a la Beth's. ($0.60 a seed! oy!) I started two today in matching sponges, so they'll start out equal at germination. Then hoping to plant one in the dishtub, another in a pot, under the same lights, and compare. Cucino are parthenocarpic, and supposed to be good for indoor and cool weather growing.
Sorry about the cuke, they are a flippin' pain to grow - but, we all keep coming back to try again and again... Never got that. 
Materials: $4.72, plus stuff I had on hand. Making a second would cost $1.88 (a second dish tub - have leftover paint tray liners and scrubby net
).
Built net pots inspired by this how-to article.
In hindsight, I think the idea was to keep less of the bottle top, and suspend the net from the lid. That wouldn't work well in this case, anyway, though. My lid is flimsy, really only to keep light out, not suspend heavy things. And I think it would break the cuke roots to pull the lid up after the roots grow into the hydroton. Such is life.
Though it's a 3-gallon dishtub, only about 1.75 gallons fit into it, what with the depth of the lid and hydroton displacement.
And placed on hearth in my office under my old two-T8 seed-starting lights rig (still same bulbs). I grew a cuke under these lights this summer, in a soil pot, but thought there wasn't enough light, and unfortunately put it outside, where it didn't fare too well. Later, maybe I'll add a second cheap shop light, for 4 48" lights.
Added seedling heat mat the next day - cukes like heat. Unfortunately, I have no warm spots to give them for the next 4+ months. This spot should stay around 60-70 degrees through the winter. (A lot warmer than the garage...)
So far so good. Eventually, will probably have only 1 cucumber plant in that volume of light space, but will see how far two get. Will probably put other things under the lights while the cukes grow, but they get big fast.